A tall stack of freshly baked chocolate chip cookies

Small-batch bakery · Tallahassee, Florida

Handcrafted Cookies. Made to Be Remembered.

Scratch-made cookies, baked fresh in small batches and available for local pickup, delivery, and shipping.

Shop Cookies Shop Local Treats

Build Your Cookie Box

Pick the box that fits the moment.

Choose your flavors. Choose your box size. We’ll handle the rest.

$17

2 oz each

Build this box

$30

2 oz each

Build this box

$48

2 oz each

Build this box

Premium flavors

White Chocolate Macadamia and Brown Butter Pecan are an additional $1 per cookie.

How It Works

Fresh cookies, made simple.

Choose Your Cookies

Select your flavors and box size.

We Bake Fresh

Your cookies are prepared and packaged with care.

Enjoy Your Treats

Choose local pickup, delivery, or shipping.

Shipping Monday–Wednesday for optimum freshness.

Orders placed after Wednesday ship the following Monday.

View shipping details

Seven signature flavors

Chocolate Chunk

M&M's

Sugar Cookie

Red Velvet

White Choc Macadamia

Brown Butter Pecan

Cookie Monster

Chocolate Chunk

M&M's

Sugar Cookie

Red Velvet

White Choc Macadamia

Brown Butter Pecan

Cookie Monster

Local pickup & delivery

Pies, cakes & cupcakes.

See all treats

Pies

Sweet Potato Pie

Silky roasted sweet potato, brown sugar, warm spice, flaky butter crust.

From $25

Cakes

Pound Cake

Dense, buttery, tender crumb — baked to order in lemon or vanilla.

From $40

Cakes

Iced Pound Cake

Our pound cake finished with a poured glaze. Lemon or vanilla.

From $45

Nortasha, the baker behind The Treat Bar

Meet the Baker

Baking knowledge, backed by food-safety expertise.

Nortasha brings a Master of Science in Biological and Environmental Sciences, a Biology background, and food-safety and quality-assurance experience dating back to 2014. That expertise shapes how every ingredient is handled and every batch is prepared, baked, and packaged.

Meet Nortasha

Quality You Can Taste. Standards You Can Trust.

Every order is made with careful ingredient handling, clean preparation practices, and consistent quality checks—so homemade flavor comes with professional care.

Catering & Treat Tables

Planning Something Special?

From birthdays and showers to corporate events and celebrations, The Treat Bar creates custom dessert experiences for your occasion.

Inquire About Catering

Instagram

Follow the Sweetness.

@thetreatbarllc

Pink & white swirl cupcakes by the dozen

Purple & cream cupcakes with gold sprinkles and pearls

Fresh from the oven

Join the mailing list.

Seasonal drops, new flavors and pickup alerts. No spam—just treats.